Comments: Dr. Rose repaired my knee when I practically destroyed it in a big skiing accident, tearing my ACL as well as severely damaging both my medial and lateral menisci and my articular cartilage on my femoral condyle. It was a long (3 hour) surgery and I remember after I came to in the post-op a hospital staff member asked me who did my knee. When I told him it was Dr. Rose, he nodded his head and said "Good. He's the best doctor at the hospital." I have to agree. I've since gone back for a few followups and have always been impressed by his demeanor and especially his talent with the knife, which is amazing. A lot of people in NYC say their orthopedic surgeon is "the best" but with Dr. Rose that is definitely the case.